Badger 5 vs Badger 5XP – Check Which One Is Best & Why?

Why Do I Recommend The Badger 5XP? 

• The Badger 5XP has a powerful 3/4 HP Dura-Drive induction motor for handling tougher food scraps with less chance of stalling, compared to the Badger 5’s 1/2 HP motor.
• Badger 5XP features higher torque output for breaking down dense waste like small bones and fibrous vegetable peels more efficiently than the Badger 5.
• It includes a longer 6-year in-home service warranty for extended protection against repairs and replacement costs, compared to the Badger 5’s 2-year coverage.
• The Badger 5XP has a slightly larger 32 oz grind chamber for accommodating more food waste at once, reducing the need for multiple disposal cycles, compared to the Badger 5’s 26 oz capacity.
• Badger 5XP supports higher amperage operation for maintaining consistent grinding power under heavy loads, while the Badger 5 may slow under similar conditions.
• It comes with the Quick Lock mounting system but with a sturdier motor build for long-term durability, reducing the frequency of unit replacements compared to the Badger 5.
• The Badger 5XP includes galvanized steel grinding components with stronger motor pairing for extending service life and resisting wear better than the Badger 5 under heavy usage.
• Badger 5XP has a slightly heavier and more stable build for reducing vibration during operation, which helps maintain quieter and smoother performance compared to the Badger 5.

Maybe the Badger 5 price can make you comfortable because it’s a little bit cheaper than the Badger 5XP. But you have to compromise all the above-mentioned features. Now the Decision is Yours. I hope it was helpful to choose the right one.

What Common Both Can Do?

• Brand & Manufacturer: Both are made by InSinkErator, ensuring similar build quality standards, design language, and reliability expectations.
• Product Type: Each model is a continuous feed garbage disposal, meaning they operate continuously while switched on, allowing waste to be fed in without stopping the motor.
• Motor Type: Both use an induction motor with Dura-Drive technology, providing smooth, consistent torque and durability for everyday kitchen use.
• Motor Speed: Each spins at 1725 RPM, meaning the grind speed is identical; performance differences come from horsepower, not RPM.
• Grinding Stage: Both use a single-stage grinding process, breaking food down in one pass before it’s flushed into the drain.
• Grinding Components Material: Both feature galvanized steel grinding parts, which are durable for standard food waste but not as corrosion-resistant as stainless steel.
• Feed Type: Each uses continuous feed operation for convenience in adding food scraps during use.
• Mounting Type: Both use InSinkErator’s Quick Lock mount system, making installation and replacements simple and compatible with each other.
• Power Cord Option: Both are sold in corded or non-corded variants, so they can be hardwired or plugged in depending on installation needs.
• Voltage Requirement: Both require a standard 120V AC power supply, common in most U.S. kitchens.
• Sound Insulation Level: Neither has advanced sound reduction technology, so noise levels are similar.
• Reset Button: Each includes a manual reset overload protector to prevent motor burnout if jammed.
• Compact Size for Under-Sink Fit: Both are designed to fit in standard under-sink spaces without requiring extra clearance.
• Housing Material: Each has galvanized steel housing for durability against standard wear and tear.
• Splash Guard: Both come with a removable splash guard, making it easier to clean and maintain the disposal inlet.